Scarlet Hollow

Scarlet Hollow

Fair · RPG · 2021 · Early Access

Steam Deck Verified

The verdict

NO RUSH.

Winter Sale 2026 Dec 17
cut in 8 of 8 sales

Fair at $29.99. A BANGER at $8.90, lower than any Steam price we have tracked since Jun 2021 (lowest $15.99, Oct 2021).

Cost per hourLowering the score
$7.14/hr
ReviewsBreakdown grade S, from S best to D worst
98% of 5,421
Critics
91 players 7 higher
Genre rank
Top 9% RPG

Holding it back: Cost per hour, Early access

Why
It needs 70% off ($8.90) to be a BANGER.
Worth it at $22.26.
Watch this gameOne alert at $8.90 or less.

Time and effort

Main story
4.2h
To 100%
37.5h 8.9x the story
Finish
2% reach the ending
Achievements
221

Price and sales

Sales
55 on record
Typical cut
25% off
Steam low
$15.99 October 2021
Sale every
36d last October 2026
Lowest now on Steamall-time low $15.99 on IsThereAnyDeal

Players and genre

Online
54 Nov 11, 07:47 UTC
Recent reviews
99% 30 days
Cheaper than
5% of its genre
Better reviewed
99% of its genre
Price and player charts

The drop-off

88% start to 2% finish

Player drop-off curve. Hover, tap or use the arrow keys for the unlock rate at a point.

Steam counts fewer than one in ten of its players at the ending achievement. Steam global achievements

The value story

The value story

Across all 55 discounts in the 5 years tracked, the median cut is 25 percent, about 5 weeks apart. No sale on record has reached $8.90, the price it would take to be a BANGER.

Its score puts it in the top 9 percent of the games it competes with. It is pricier than 95 percent of its genre, and better reviewed than 99 percent. Among the games that feel like it, Kindergarten ($4.99, scores 91) beats it on value, while it beats The Casting of Frank Stone™ ($29.99, scores 5).

More about Scarlet Hollow

Steam's global achievement data puts about 2 percent of players at this game's ending achievement. On a 4.2-hour game, the hours short of it still count in its price per hour. Of the 402 Steam-purchase reviews this site sampled, 1 comes from a buyer who refunded the game, sampled from reviews written June 2021 to August 2026. Inside the two-hour refund window, 92 percent of the 141 reviews written there were positive, against 98 percent overall, and those are 3 percent of the reviews sampled.

The main story runs 4.2 hours. Doing everything runs 38, 8.9 times as long.

It carries Valve's Deck Verified rating and runs 4.2 hours, about as long as a handheld game wants to be.

Buy now or wait

Buy now or wait

Discounted in each of its last 8 seasonal sales. Last discount ended 7 days ago.

Next sale
Winter Sale, Dec 17 to Jan 4

Sources: IsThereAnyDeal, Valve.

What drives the score

Grades: S best, D weakest

S is the best grade and D the weakest, judged as a buyer. ▲ raises the score, ▼ lowers it, ? is an input we do not have, • is a fact this genre's score does not use. How the grades work

Raising the score
Reviews
Gates the score. Weak reviews cap it, and nothing reaches BANGER without strong ones
Engagement2% finish
How far players get (achievements). It can only add points
Holding it back
Cost per hour$7.14/hr
Price per hour of game. It moves the score inside the ceiling reviews set
Early accessUnfinished
Still in development, a small confidence discount until 1.0
For context
MonetizationNot known
No monetization record for this game, so nothing is assumed either way
Refunds1 of 402 reviews
Steam-purchase reviews sampled whose writer refunded the game. Nothing is docked
AI contentNone disclosed
From the developer's own Steam disclosure. No disclosure is not proof of none, so it does not move the score

What players say

This is my first time writing a review for any game and I think that's the first thing you should know, about how much I've enjoyed and keep enjoying it. I showed it to my brother after playing only a bit of the first and second chapters, already liking it but unaware yet of just how much I'd end up loving it. Work kept getting in the way. Well, a week later and we've played and talked of nothing else. We are...
JavRecommendedafter 36h8 found this helpfulearly accessRead on Steam
2 more reviews
I'm somehow 23.4 hours into a, what, 8 hour game? And an unfinished one at that? And I'm 7 concurrent playthroughs in? As someone who has never been super into visual-novel style games, choice-heavy or not, it's really strange to find myself so addicted. Both the writing and the amount of unique art are really impressive, and most of all, the amount of variance in how things can play out is completely nuts. Not to...
smuhqRecommendedafter 23hSep 2026early accessRead on Steam
I came into this game as a gigantic fan of Slay The Princess. If you liked that game PLEASE play this one. If you're totally new to this studio, play both games! I saw another review label this game as 'pure hubris' on the part of the devs because of just how intricate and reactive the different choices are. Slay the Princess is a superb game, but it pales in comparison in the 'choices matter' department. If you've...
dreaminlemurRecommendedafter 34hSep 2026early accessRead on Steam

Steam reviews. Opinions are theirs.

About the game

Your aunt’s dead, your cousin hates you, and you’re stuck in the dead-end town of Scarlet Hollow. Choose your path through a branching narrative so dense that you'll see less than 1/5 of the game on a single playthrough. You won't be able to save everyone. Good luck, and welcome home.
Description from the Steam store page.
Minimum specs

Minimum on the Steam store: 2 GB of memory, Integrated Graphics, 2 GB of storage. Runs on Windows, macOS, Linux.

Cite this score

BANG Score badge
Scarlet Hollow scores 63/100 on the BANG Score (fair value) as of Nov 17, 2026. The BANG Score rates what a game is worth for the money. Via Steam BANGERS. https://steambangers.com/game/1609230/scarlet-hollow
Embed the live badge

Reviews set the ceiling, and price against real length moves the BANG Score inside it. How it works, and where it is weak → Steam reviews as of Oct 31, price as of Nov 17. A number here look wrong? Tell me and I will check the inputs.

Critics vs players+7
Critics91
Players98
Metacritic critics · 5,421 Steam player reviews

Details

DeveloperBlack Tabby Games
PublisherBlack Tabby Games
GenreRPG
Released2021
Players75Kowners, SteamSpy estimate
Achievements221