Pony Island

Pony Island

Worth it · Short indie · 2016

Steam Deck Verified

The verdict

BUY IT.

Winter Sale 2026 Dec 17
cut in 5 of 8 sales

Worth it at $4.99. Typically $0.74 in seasonal sales. The Winter Sale opens Dec 17.

Cost per hourLowering the score
$2.08/hr
ReviewsBreakdown grade S, from S best to D worst
95% of 19,724
Critics
86 players 9 higher
Genre rank
Top 1% Short indie

Holding it back: Cost per hour

Why
It needs 7% off ($4.62) to be a BANGER.
Watch this gameOne alert at $4.62 or less.

Time and effort

Main story
2.4h
To 100%
4.7h 2.0x the story
Achievements
20

Price and sales

Sales
51 on record
Typical cut
67% off
Steam low
$0.74 December 2023
Sale every
52d last December 2025
Lowest now $4.39 at Fanaticalall-time low $0.74 on IsThereAnyDeal

Players and genre

Online
108 Nov 10, 13:46 UTC
Recent reviews
91% 30 days
Cheaper than
32% of its genre
Better reviewed
98% of its genre
Price and player charts

The drop-off

89% start to 7% rarest

Player drop-off curve. Hover, tap or use the arrow keys for the unlock rate at a point.

This site could not identify an ending achievement for this game, so there is no finish rate. Steam global achievements

The value story

The value story

51 discounts in the 11 years on record, a median of 67 percent off across all of them, roughly 7 weeks apart. Today it is at full price, and its last discount ended about 45 weeks ago.

Its score sits in the top 1 percent of its genre. It is pricier than 68 percent of its genre, and better reviewed than 98 percent. Among the games closest to it, The Hex ($9.99, scores 73) and Kindergarten 2 ($14.99, scores 73) both come in lower.

More about Pony Island

The press gave it 86; the people who bought it give it 95 percent. A 9-point gap in the buyer's favour.

3 of the 740 Steam-purchase reviews sampled here come from buyers who refunded the game, sampled from reviews written March 2020 to October 2026. Inside the two-hour refund window, 84 percent of the 1,730 reviews written there were positive, against 95 percent overall, and those are 12 percent of the reviews sampled.

It carries Valve's Deck Verified rating and runs 2.4 hours, about as long as a handheld game wants to be.

Buy now or wait

Buy now or wait

Discounted in 5 of its last 8 seasonal sales. Last discount ended 316 days ago.

Sources: IsThereAnyDeal, Valve.

What drives the score

Grades: S best, D weakest

S is the best grade and D the weakest, judged as a buyer. ▲ raises the score, ▼ lowers it, ? is an input we do not have, • is a fact this genre's score does not use. How the grades work

Raising the score
Reviews
Gates the score. Weak reviews cap it, and nothing reaches BANGER without strong ones
MonetizationNone
Checked: no in-game purchases or loot boxes. That earns a small credit unless Steam lists in-app purchases
Holding it back
Cost per hour$2.08/hr
Price per hour of game. It moves the score inside the ceiling reviews set
For context
Refunds3 of 740 reviews
Steam-purchase reviews sampled whose writer refunded the game. Nothing is docked
AI contentNone disclosed
From the developer's own Steam disclosure. No disclosure is not proof of none, so it does not move the score

What players say

Remember the dinosaur from Chrome when you don't have Internet? This is him now. From gameplay perspective this is mainly about ponies jumping and trying to avoid the fences. But as you know, this is a little bit cursed this time. I have played Inscryption before this game, so I knew what to expect from this developer and was not dissapointed. At times, this game feels like proto-inscryption, with some ideas and...
Vlad_MolibozhenkoRecommendedafter 5.7h89 found this helpfulRead on Steam
2 more reviews
wait for end of the -100% sale to get this game so they can make another masterpiece like Inscrpytion
Efec99Recommendedafter 2.9h16 found this helpfulRead on Steam
Pretty cool game. I think maybe uhhh maybeeee you play it. have a good time. there's a horse. and some other stuff. yeah! pretty nice. i like it. thanks.
OctogeniusRecommendedafter 2.3h8 found this helpfulRead on Steam

Steam reviews, rotated daily. Opinions are theirs.

About the game

Pony Island is a suspense puzzle game in disguise. You are in limbo, trapped in a malevolent and malfunctioning arcade machine devised by the devil himself. It is not a game about ponies.
Description from the Steam store page.
Minimum specs

Minimum on the Steam store: 2 GB of memory, 399 MB of storage. Runs on Windows, macOS, Linux.

Cite this score

BANG Score badge
Pony Island scores 84/100 on the BANG Score (worth it) as of Nov 17, 2026. The BANG Score rates what a game is worth for the money. Via Steam BANGERS. https://steambangers.com/game/405640/pony-island
Embed the live badge

Reviews set the ceiling, and price against real length moves the BANG Score inside it. How it works, and where it is weak → Steam reviews as of Nov 10, price as of Nov 16. A number here look wrong? Tell me and I will check the inputs.

Critics vs players+9
Critics86
Players95
Metacritic critics · 19,724 Steam player reviews

Details

DeveloperDaniel Mullins Games
PublisherDaniel Mullins Games
GenreShort indie
Released2016
Players750Kowners, SteamSpy estimate
Achievements20