Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments

Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments

Fair · Narrative · 2014

Steam Deck Verified

The verdict

WAIT.

Winter Sale 2026 Dec 17
cut in 8 of 8 sales

Fair today. The Winter Sale opens Dec 17, and it was discounted in 8 of its last 8 seasonal sales; 90% in the Winter Sale 2025.

Today

$29.99Fair

Typical seasonal cut

$2.9990% offWorth it

Cost per hourLowering the score
$2.38/hr
ReviewsBreakdown grade A, from S best to D worst
90% of 8,109
Critics
77 players 13 higher
Genre rank
Top 10% Narrative

Holding it back: Cost per hour

Why
It needs 26% off ($22.21) to be worth it, though reviews keep it under BANGER.
Watch this gameOne alert at $2.99 or less.

Time and effort

Main story
12.6h
To 100%
15.5h 1.2x the story
Finish
29% reach the ending
Achievements
25

Price and sales

Sales
105 on record
Typical cut
80% off
Steam low
$2.99 August 2020
Sale every
35d last October 2026
Lowest now $2.99 at GOGall-time low $2.08 on IsThereAnyDeal

Players and genre

Online
34 Nov 12, 15:46 UTC
Cheaper than
2% of its genre
Better reviewed
90% of its genre
Price and player charts

The drop-off

58% start to 29% finish

Player drop-off curve. Hover, tap or use the arrow keys for the unlock rate at a point.

Steam counts a larger share of its players at the ending achievement than it does for most games this site can measure. Steam global achievements

The value story

The value story

105 discounts in the 12 years on record, a median of 80 percent off across all of them, roughly 5 weeks apart. Today it is at full price, and its last discount ended about 2 weeks ago.

Against its own genre its score lands in the top 10 percent. It is pricier than 98 percent of its genre, and better reviewed than 90 percent. Among the games that feel like it, The Rise of the Golden Idol ($19.99, scores 71) beats it on value, while it beats Sherlock Holmes: The Devil's Daughter ($29.99, scores 43).

More about Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments

The press gave it 77; the people who bought it give it 90 percent. A 13-point gap in the buyer's favour.

Steam's global achievement data puts 29 percent of players at this game's ending achievement. The median game this site can measure sits at 18. Of the 800 Steam-purchase reviews this site sampled, 8 come from buyers who refunded the game, sampled from reviews written September 2020 to November 2026. That is fewer refunded reviewers than 7 in 10 paid games this site has sampled to the same depth, and among the 1,628 games in its genre sampled this deeply, 907 have a larger share. Inside the two-hour refund window, 53 percent of the 440 reviews written there were positive, against 90 percent overall, and those are 6 percent of the reviews sampled.

Valve rates it Steam Deck Verified, and at 12.6 hours it is short enough to finish on one.

Buy now or wait

Buy now or wait

Last discount ended 17 days ago.

Sources: IsThereAnyDeal, Valve.

What drives the score

Grades: S best, D weakest

S is the best grade and D the weakest, judged as a buyer. ▲ raises the score, ▼ lowers it, ? is an input we do not have, • is a fact this genre's score does not use. How the grades work

Raising the score
Reviews
Gates the score. Weak reviews cap it, and nothing reaches BANGER without strong ones. Scored as 89% after the small-sample adjustment
Engagement29% finish
How far players get (achievements). It can only add points
Holding it back
Cost per hour$2.38/hr
Price per hour of game. It moves the score inside the ceiling reviews set
For context
MonetizationNot known
No monetization record for this game, so nothing is assumed either way
Refunds8 of 800 reviews
Steam-purchase reviews sampled whose writer refunded the game. Nothing is docked
AI contentNone disclosed
From the developer's own Steam disclosure. No disclosure is not proof of none, so it does not move the score

What players say

A masterpiece of detective gaming held back only by its age. If you are thinking of picking up Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments, it is widely considered the peak of Frogwares' detective series and holds up incredibly well today. While the brilliant deduction mechanics and atmospheric mysteries will absolutely keep you hooked, the game has a few minor technical and pacing quirks that show its age. Here is what...
A Steam playerRecommendedafter 2.3h4 found this helpfulRead on Steam
2 more reviews
A fantastic detective game! I had a great time playing Sherlock Holmes: Crimes & Punishments. The game features six cases that kept me engaged from beginning to end, and I thoroughly enjoyed the process of investigating, gathering clues, connecting the dots, and trying to figure out what had really happened. Of course, I didn't always get it right, which was part of the fun. This was my first Sherlock Holmes game in...
A Steam playerRecommendedafter 12h3 found this helpfulRead on Steam
Arthur Conan Doyle would be proud Holy moly that was a real banger of a detective game. Eerie nostalgic atmosphere haunting you through the cases, which put you as a detective in a very realistic way. The consequences and the conclusions of the cases are entirely based on your choices, and that's an amazing mechanic that you won't see in many detective games. Voice actors are fantastic, and the characters for...
A Steam playerRecommendedafter 19h1 found this helpfulRead on Steam

Steam reviews. Opinions are theirs.

About the game

Become the most celebrated detective of all time: Sherlock Holmes! Use your impressive talents as a detective to solve six thrilling and varied cases: murders, missing persons, spectacular thefts and numerous investigations that sometimes lead you into the realms of the fantastic.
Description from the Steam store page.
Minimum specs

Minimum on the Steam store: 2 GB of memory, 14 GB of storage. Windows only.

Cite this score

BANG Score badge
Sherlock Holmes: Crimes and Punishments scores 63/100 on the BANG Score (fair value) as of Nov 17, 2026. The BANG Score rates what a game is worth for the money. Via Steam BANGERS. https://steambangers.com/game/241260/sherlock-holmes-crimes-and-punishments
Embed the live badge

Reviews set the ceiling, and price against real length moves the BANG Score inside it. How it works, and where it is weak → Steam reviews as of Nov 13, price as of Nov 16. A number here look wrong? Tell me and I will check the inputs.

Critics vs players+13
Critics77
Players90
Player favorite. The critics underrated it.
Metacritic critics · 8,109 Steam player reviews

Details

DeveloperFrogwares
PublisherFrogwares
GenreNarrative
Released2014
Players350Kowners, SteamSpy estimate
Achievements25