New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia Collector's Edition
Fair · Narrative · 2015
Steam Deck PlayableThe verdict
NO RUSH.
Fair at $9.99. Buy it if you want it.
- Length
- 3.7h 7.6h to 100%
- Value
- $2.70/hr
- Reviews
- 92% of 343 positive
Watch this gameOne alert at $7.35 or less.
Buy now or wait
Discounted in 2 of its last 8 seasonal sales. Last cut ended 48 days ago.
- Next sale
- Winter Sale, Dec 17 to Jan 4
Sources: IsThereAnyDeal, Valve.
What drives the score
How to read this
Grades run S to D, read from the buyer's side. ▲ marks a lift, ▼ a drag or a dock, ? an input we do not have, • a fact this genre's score does not use. How the grades work
About the game
A captivating detective adventure with elements of mysticism, telling a story of kidnapped children and mafia bosses.
Minimum specs
Minimum on the Steam store: 512 MB of memory, 952 MB of storage. Runs on Windows, macOS.
The value story
Across all 48 discounts in the 11 years tracked, the median cut is 60 percent, about 12 weeks apart. Today it is at full price, and its last discount ended about 7 weeks ago.
Against its own genre it lands in the top 10 percent on value. It is pricier than 68 percent of its genre, and better reviewed than 90 percent. Among the games that feel like it, Enigmatis 3: The Shadow of Karkhala ($14.99, scores 64) beats it on value, while it beats Clockwork Tales: Of Glass and Ink ($14.99, scores 60).
More about New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia Collector's Edition
The main story runs 3.7 hours. Doing everything runs 8, 2.1 times as long.
The drop-off
90% start to 10% rarestNo achievement in this game marks the ending, so there is no finish rate. The curve runs from the most-unlocked achievement to the rarest, and its shape is where players stop. Steam global achievements
Players
- Players online
- 4 when we last checked, on Oct 9, 14:56 UTC
Player counts from the Steam Web API.
What players say
What can I say? I am familiar with Five-BN games via their "Lost Lands" and "Darkness and Flame" series (Fourth doesn't exist) and they always had something interesting going on. Whether it be a mystery that makes you think or the game play itself is fun... You are there for the Hidden Object experience of it all. Here is no different. This also seems to be the first game listed on their page and I was awake for the...
2 more reviews
Save mafia bosses... and children! ... in this quirky title An odd little game that somehow has this crazy premise, but makes it work with some solid gameplay. So many hidden object games follow the formula of playing as a detective because it works so well with the exploration and puzzle-solving aspects of the game - and this one gets it bang on. Not only is the protagonist quite a 'looker', or beautiful 'broad' if...
This is actually a pretty great HOG puzzle adventure game. It's a modern HOG, meaning that there are no classic HOG scenes where you just find objects; instead, you solve small puzzles on every HOG scene. It also has collectibles and extra stuff to find in every area. Very decent playtime too, almost 9 hours! When I read it had to do with the mafia, I thought I might not get into it, since it's a topic I'm not...
Steam reviews, mixed to its ratio and rotated daily. Opinions are theirs.
No data upstream: critic score (Metacritic).
Cite this score
New York Mysteries: Secrets of the Mafia Collector's Edition scores 63/100 on the BANG Score (fair value) as of Oct 19, 2026. The BANG Score rates what a game is worth for the money. Via Steam BANGERS. https://steambangers.com/game/372930/new-york-mysteries-secrets-of-the-mafia-collector-s-editionReviews set the ceiling, and price against real length moves the BANG Score inside it. How it works, and where it is weak → Steam reviews as of Sep 29, price as of Oct 18. A number here look wrong? Tell me and I will check the inputs.